
Designed to Help Healing: Renowned Architect I.M. Pei Overcomes Project's Restraints
and Creates an Uplifiting Environment for UCLA Hospital
By NICOLAI OUROUSSOFF, Los Angeles Times Architecture Critic
Light, Nature, the scale of the human body-the modernists believed
these elements could be used to cure many of the world's social ills.
Few architects have clung to that faith more than I.M. Pei, the
octogenarian who has translated that formula into myriad highly
refined architectural landmarks.
At 86,Pei is approaching the twilight of a long and successful
career that includes the redesign of Paris' Louvre, Boston's
Hancock Tower, the East Wing of Washington's National Gallery-
all icons in their repective cities. So it came as a surprise
a year ago that Pei had decided to take on UCLA's $600-million
new hospital, the largest component in a $1.3-billion medical
complex that will replacethe existing facility, which was damaged
during the 1994 Northridge earthquake. Hospitals are notoriously
cursed commisions for architects; Complex organizational requirements
and high cost of increasingly sophisticated technological hardware
mean that architecture inevitably becomes a secondary concern.
Yet Pei's design, unveiled Jan. 19, shows us how even the most
fundamental architectural tools-when skillfully manipulated-can
do much to foster a humane environment even under extreme
constraints. This is not one of Pei's greatest works, but
given the project's constraints, the project is a masterful
piece of light, nature, and scale-one where architecture can
function as an integral tool in the healing of the human psyche.
In that sense, it is a critical step toward a more enlightened
understanding of health care.
The existing medical center faces Westwood Plaza, embedded in a
maze of parking structures on the extension of Westwood Boulevard
that forms the main entry to the school's medical campus. Completed
in 1954, the original structure was organized as two elongated
parallel buildings, one housing doctors and research, other patients,
with offices tucked in between. But during a series of subsequent
expansions the complex evolved into a labyrinth of interlocking
buildings. The center is now a chaotic, 3.1 million-square-foot
complex whose repetitive rooms are bound together by 27 miles of
corridors where patients, doctors, and visitors scurry back
and forth with rat-like determination. It is a structure that
fosters anxiety, not calm.
The new design, by comparison, will be an oasis of rationality.
Conceived as a cluster of smaller communities,
the first three floors form a massive plinth that unify the design.
In order to preserve the sense of order, however, there are three
main entries: Most inpatients will enter through the east lobby from
a landscaped rotunda at one end of Westwood Plaza, while pediatric
patients will arrive from the west, along a second, tree-lined
drive along Gayley Avenue. Trauma patients, meanwhile, enter
through a more discreet entry along Charles E. Young Drive South
or will be flown onto one of two helicopter pads, from where
they wishoot down into the building via high-speed elevators.
The separation of patients and families into distinct,
interdependent units, however, is strongest on the upper floors,
where Pei breaks the building mass into four semi-detached volumes,
creating a more comforting sense of scale. Arranged in clusters
of 32 rooms, the wards connect on each floor through light-filled
public rooms. Pei has staggered the towers so that windows won't
look directly in on each other-a trick he used in his 1961 design
for New York's University Village-allowing light to spill in from
all sides and opening up views. Inside, each of the 525 rooms-all
of them private-is equipped with an oversized window seat that
can be converted into a bed, where visitors can curl up at night
alongside the patients they are visiting. The idea is to create
a hierarchy of increasingly intimate communities-an antidote to
beaureaucratic anonymity.
Pei Lamented in a recent interview that the site's size does
not allow for more public space, something he feels would have
strengthened the building's design. Ideally, on a site twice as
big, the entry level would have opened onto large internal gardens,
lobbies would have soared. Equally important, the upper floors
would have included more generous public rooms, large terraces
where patients could escape the confinement of their rooms
to mingle with one another or rest in the fresh air and light. And
the architectural forms-with more room to breath-might have been
closer to the strong geometrical compositions that have marked Pei's
buildings in the past. Here, the forms are somewhat dull and static.
Nonetheless, Pei has found ways to infuse his design with nature
and light. On the ground floor, a partially sheltered garden
court flanks the hospital's east lobby, where visitors can
temporarily escape the bustle of the hospital within, while to
the south, an outdoor restaurant plaza connects the building to the
existing Medical Plaza. The triangular form of the structure's
southern glass facade-flanked by two stone-clad towers- steps back
to create a series of outdoorterraces. Pei's desire-to create a
more open, therapeutic environment-extends beyond the boundaries of
the complex. Pei wants to connect the new structure to a larger
urban context, to fuse this cloistered world within a city. In his
scheme, an alley of eucalyptus trees will line Westwood Plaza to
conceal the banal existing buildings and give the campus a strong
central axis. A traffic circle will mark the hospital's main entry
and help bind together the medical campus' various buildings.
Reflecting pools will add an element of restfulness to the scheme,
which seeks to turn what is now a bustling, chaotic urban street
into a more calming, bucolic context. The idea is that architecture,
too, can heal, that it can function as a framework for an enlightened
community, one that can even uplift the soul.
During the 1920s, avant-garde architects such as Konstantin Melnikov
proposed highly rational environments that were intended to heal
their inhabitants both morally anhysically. Melnikov's Laboratory
of Sleep-never built-was intended to lull workers into a magically
rejuvenating dream world. In the Hollywood Hills, Richard Neustra's
1927 Lovell Health House with its open steel and glass frame
was meant to have similar-if less fantastic-therapeutic qualities.
Such idealism has since been tempered by the well-recorded
failures of postwar urbanism. Modernism's utopia bent has long
been supplanted by architecture that seeks to reveal the inherent
complexity of our social and cultural structures rather than to
transform it. In that sense, Pei's architecture to accomplish so
much it insists on architecture's humanist mission, on its ability
to elevate the human condition.